Central and East European
Society for Phenomenology

Repository | Journal | Volume | Article

238362

Decision-theoretic epistemology

Ruth Weintraub

pp. 159-177

Abstract

In this paper, I examine the possibility of accounting for the rationality of belief-formation by utilising decision-theoretic considerations. I consider the utilities to be used by such an approach, propose to employ verisimilitude as a measure of cognitive utility, and suggest a natural way of generalising any measure of verisimilitude defined on propositions to partial belief-systems, a generalisation which may enable us to incorporate Popper's insightful notion of verisimilitude within a Bayesian framework. I examine a dilemma generated by the decision-theoretic procedure and consider an adequacy condition (immodesty) designed to ameliorate one of its horns. Finally, I argue in a sceptical vein that no adequate verisimilitude measure can be used decision-theoretically.

Publication details

Published in:

(1990) Synthese 83 (1).

Pages: 159-177

DOI: 10.1007/BF00413691

Full citation:

Weintraub Ruth (1990) „Decision-theoretic epistemology“. Synthese 83 (1), 159–177.