Central and East European
Society for Phenomenology

Repository | Journal | Volume | Article

234345

Informational dynamics of epistemic possibility modals

Peter Hawke Shane Steinert-Threlkeld

pp. 4309-4342

Abstract

We investigate, in a logical setting, the expressivist proposal that assertion primarily functions to express and coordinate doxastic states and that ‘might’ fundamentally expresses lack of belief. We provide a formal model of an agent’s doxastic state and novel assertability conditions for an associated formal language. We thereby prove that an arbitrary assertion (including a complex of ‘might’ and ‘factual’ claims) always succeeds in expressing a well-defined (partial) doxastic state, and propose a fully general and intuitive update operation as a model of an agent coming to accept an arbitrary assertion. Leaving a comprehensive philosophical and linguistic defense for elsewhere, we explore technical aspects of our framework, providing, for instance, a complete logic of assertability and reduction axioms for the novel update operations related to our proposal. Finally, we contrast our work with related proposals in the logic literature.

Publication details

Published in:

van der Hoek Wiebe, Holliday Wesley H., Wang Wen-fang (2018) Logic, rationality and interaction (LORI-5). Synthese 195 (10).

Pages: 4309-4342

DOI: 10.1007/s11229-016-1216-8

Full citation:

Hawke Peter, Steinert-Threlkeld Shane (2018) „Informational dynamics of epistemic possibility modals“. Synthese 195 (10), 4309–4342.