Central and East European
Society for Phenomenology

Repository | Journal | Volume | Article

234975

Understanding phenomena

Christoph Kelp

pp. 3799-3816

Abstract

The literature on the nature of understanding can be divided into two broad camps. Explanationists believe that it is knowledge of explanations that is key to understanding. In contrast, their manipulationist rivals maintain that understanding essentially involves an ability to manipulate certain representations. The aim of this paper is to provide a novel knowledge based account of understanding. More specifically, it proposes an account of maximal understanding of a given phenomenon in terms of fully comprehensive and maximally well-connected knowledge of it and of degrees of understanding in terms of approximations to such knowledge. It is completed by a contextualist semantics for outright attributions of understanding according to which an attribution of understanding is true of one just in case one knows enough about it to perform some contextually determined task. It is argued that this account has an edge over both its explanationist and manipulationist competitors.

Publication details

Published in:

Eronen Markus, van Riel Raphael (2015) Understand though modeling. Synthese 192 (12).

Pages: 3799-3816

DOI: 10.1007/s11229-014-0616-x

Full citation:

Kelp Christoph (2015) „Understanding phenomena“. Synthese 192 (12), 3799–3816.